Skip to main content

Table 3 Performance comparison of different formulas

From: Accuracy of refractive outcomes using standard or total keratometry for intraocular lens power formulas in conventional cataract surgery

Formula

FPI

ME

SD

MAE

MedAE

Percentage of eyes within PE (%)

± 0.25 D

± 0.50 D

± 0.75 D

± 1.00 D

± 2.00 D

BUII

0.072

0.000

0.448

0.259

0.341

46.085

74.497

90.828

95.749

100

BUII TK

0.071

0.000

0.451

0.266

0.343

44.743

72.036

90.604

96.421

100

P value

 

0.999

  

0.759

0.245

0.824

0.641

  

Haigis

0.065

0.002

0.503

0.296

0.388

41.256

70.179

87.668

93.946

100

Haigis TK

0.062

0.000

0.511

0.317

0.399

39.597

67.785

84.787

93.736

100

P value

 

0.855

  

0.105

0.203

0.744

0.129

  

SRK/T

0.061

0.000

0.541

0.333

0.416

39.821

68.233

85.235

93.065

100

SRK/T TK

0.061

-0.007

0.545

0.331

0.423

37.584

68.233

82.774

93.512

100

P value

 

0.365

  

0.365

0.563

0.995

0.021

  

H2

0.060

0.000

0.567

0.334

0.434

36.689

67.562

82.998

92.841

100

H2 TK

0.058

0.000

0.562

0.360

0.433

36.913

65.548

83.669

92.841

100

P value

 

0.999

  

0.847

0.785

> 0.99

0.544

  
  1. FPI = formulas performance index; ME = mean error; SD = standard deviation; MAE = mean absolute error; MedAE = median absolute error; PE = prediction error; D = diopter; BUII = Barrett universal II; H2 = Holladay2.