Skip to main content

Augmented inferior rectus transposition with medial rectus recession in treatment of chronic unilateral sixth nerve palsy

Abstract

Background

to report the results of augmented inferior rectus muscle transposition (IRT) in management of chronic sixth nerve palsy.

Methods

a retrospective review of medical records of patients with chronic complete sixth nerve palsy who were treated by augmented full thickness IRT to the lateral border of the paralyzed lateral rectus muscle. Patients were selected for IRT if there was more limitation of abduction in inferior gaze associated with V- pattern esotropia. Medial rectus recession (MRRc) was performed in case of positive intraoperative forced duction. Effect on primary position esotropia, face turn, amount of V-pattern and limitation of ocular ductions were reported and analyzed.

Results

the review revealed 11 patients (7 males) with chronic unilateral sixth nerve palsy who were treated by simultaneous augmented IRT and MRRc. Causes of sixth nerve palsy were trauma (6 cases), vascular (3 cases), inflammation and congenital (one case each). Mean age of the patients at the time of surgery was 35.6 years (range; 11–63) and mean follow up was 8.6 months (range; 6–13). Postoperatively, average correction of esotropia, V-pattern, face turn and limited abduction were 35.9 PD, 11.4 PD, 25.9° and 2.2 unit, respectively (p < .00). Postoperative complications in the form anterior segment ischemia, symptomatic induced vertical deviations were not found.

Conclusions

In cases of chronic unilateral sixth nerve palsy associated with more limitation of abduction in downgaze and V-pattern esotropia, augmented IRT could be considered as an effective and safe modality.

Peer Review reports

Introduction

Various forms of vertical rectus muscle transposition (VRT) have been proposed to overcome esotropia, face turn and limited abduction associated with complete chronic sixth nerve palsy. They include partial thickness VRT [1], full thickness VRT [2] and isolated superior rectus muscle transposition (SRT) [3, 4]. Enhancement of the effect of each transposition technique could also be obtained by application of certain augmentation techniques which include scleral fixation [5], myopexy sutures [6] or combination of both [7].

Isolated SRT, as a form of single vertical rectus muscle transposition was aiming at reducing the incidence of anterior segment ischemia especially when combined with medial rectus muscle recession, and it was found effective in improving limited abduction and esotropia in chronic abducens palsy [8,9,10]. Recently, inferior rectus muscle transposition (IRT) as another modality of single vertical rectus muscle transposition in treatment of chronic sixth nerve palsy was recently introduced [11]. The aim of the current study is to evaluate the results of augmented IRT in treatment of chronic abducens palsy.

Patients and methods

This study was approved by institutional review board of Benha University hospital and it adhered the tenets of the Declaration of Helsinki. The medical records of consecutive patients with chronic non resolving complete sixth nerve palsy who underwent augmented IRT with a minimum of 6 months follow up were retrospectively reviewed. Patients were included if their sixth nerve palsy was more than 6 months duration. Patients were selected for IRT surgery if limited abduction was significantly more pronounced in the inferior gaze with associated V-pattern esotropia.

Data acquisition include patients’ demographics in the form of age at time of surgery, duration of follow up, gender, etiology and duration of sixth nerve palsy and presence of diplopia at the primary position. Full comprehensive ophthalmic and orthoptic examinations were performed preoperatively and at each postoperative visit including corrected visual acuity, cycloplegic refraction and fundus examination. Esotropia in the forced primary position was measured at both distant and near fixation using alternate prism cover test with values of distant esotropia were used for evaluation. The degree of esotropia was measured in up and downgaze, and V-pattern was diagnosed if the difference between them was ≥15 prism diopter (PD). The degree of face turn was measured in the habitual head position during distant fixation using orthoptic goniometer with 5-degree scale. Degree of limitation of ocular duction was assessed and documented using a 6- point scale [12]. Ocular torsion was objectively assessed by measuring the degree of fundus torsion or the position of the fovea relative to optic disc. Complete sixth nerve palsy was diagnosed by very minimal to no abduction force on active generation test with absent or floating saccades.

Under general anesthesia, the degree of tightness of the medial rectus muscle was assessed at the beginning of surgery using forced duction test, and in case of significant contracture, the medial rectus muscle was recessed in the usual manner by an amount sufficient to relieve the contracture, as evident by negative forced duction test. Through limbal conjunctival incision, the inferior rectus muscle was hooked and cleared from all surrounding Tennon’s capsule and fascia. Care was taken to lyse any attachment between the inferior rectus muscle and inferior lid retractors to avoid postoperative lower lid retraction. The inferior rectus muscle was imbricated close to its insertion using double armed 6/0 polyglactin 910 sutures before it was disinserted. The detached muscle was then laterally transposed and was sutured to the sclera in a crossed sword fashion adjacent to the insertion of the paralyzed lateral rectus muscle along the spiral of Tillaux. The transposition was then augmented as described by Farid by passing the needle of a non-absorbable 5/0 polyester suture through the temporal half of the transposed inferior rectus muscle then through the sclera close to the inferior border of the lateral rectus muscle and finally through the inferior third of the lateral rectus muscle 8–10 mm posterior to lateral rectus insertion [5]. Finally, the conjunctiva was closed by interrupted 7/0 polyglactin 910 sutures.

Careful slit lamp examination was performed at each visit to detect any sign of anterior segment ischemia. Values of the last postoperative visit were used for statistical analysis and comparison using paired t-test with a p value less than 0.05 was considered significant.

Results

The review reveals 11 patients who underwent unilateral IRT for treatment of unilateral chronic complete sixth nerve palsy. Mean age of patients at the time of surgery was 35.6 (range; 11–63 years) and average amount of follow up was 8.6 months (range; 6–13 months). Out of the 11 patients, 7 patients were males and the left eye was affected in 6 patients. Trauma was the leading cause of sixth nerve palsy (6 cases) followed by vascular causes (3 cases) then inflammatory and congenital (one cases each). Diplopia at the primary position was present in 9 patients at presentation and completely disappeared in all patients after surgery. Data of fundus torsion before and after surgery was available for only 4 patients. In those patients, no induced torsion was detected after surgery. Intraoperatively, medial rectus contracture was encountered in all cases as evident by positive forced duction test which mandated simultaneous medial rectus muscle recession by an amount sufficient to relieve the contracture (mean 4.5, range; 3.5–5.5 mm). Table 1 shows detailed patients characteristics pre and postoperatively.

Table 1 Patients’ demographics and surgical results

After augmented IRT, esotropia improved from 42.2 prism diopter (PD) (range; 25 to 60 PD) before surgery to 7.8 PD (range; − 8 to 20 PD) (p < .00001). Postoperative small angle consecutive exotropia developed in two patients. However, the exotropia was asymptomatic and of small magnitude (4 and 8PD) so that no further actions were needed. Face turn improved from 32.2° (range; 15 to 45°) to 6.3° (range; 0 to 20°) (p < .00001). Limitation of abduction of the affected eye improved from − 4.5 unit (range; − 4 to − 5 unit) to − 2.3 unit (range; − 1 to − 3 unit) (p < .00001), while adduction declined from 0.2 unit (range; 0 to1 unit) to − 0.3 unit (range; − 1 to 0 unit) (p = 0.0018). Postoperatively, minimal (− 1 unit) induced limitation of adduction was recorded in 3 cases (Fig. 1, Table 2).

FIG. 1
figure 1

9-gaze clinical photos of a patient with chronic posttraumatic left sixth neve palsy. A preoperative photos show 35PD primary position ET which increased in the down compared to the up gaze (V-pattern ET). Limitation of abduction in the left eye was − 5 which was less evident in the upper lateral gaze compared to lower lateral gaze. B postoperative photos following left dual augmented IRT combined with 4.5 mm medial rectus recession. Primary position alignment improved to 4PD exotropia and limited abduction to − 2. with collapse of V-pattern. Note; the left pupil was pharmacologically dilated

Table 2 Main parameters of the study before and after surgery

The average amount of V-pattern (difference between deviation in downgaze and upgaze) collapsed from 20.9 PD (range; 15 to 25 PD) preoperatively to 9.4 PD postoperatively (range; 4 to 15 PD) (p < .00001) (Fig. 1). Out of 8 patients with preoperative HT, 6 patients had reductions of up to 6 PD, with one showing a reversal to a post-operative hypotropia. One patient with no pre-existing vertical deviation developed a hypotropia. In both patients who developed postoperative hypotropia., It was asymptomatic and no further actions were required. After surgery, esotropia and face turn improved by means of 35.9PD (range; 25 − 50PD) and 25.9 degrees (range; 15–35°) respectively. Average improvement of V-pattern was 11.4 PD (range; 9–19 PD) Average improvement of limited abduction was 2.1 (range; 1 to 3) while average decline of adduction was − 0.5 (range; − 1 to 0) (Table 2).

Mild induced vertical deviation in the form induced hypotropia of 2 PD was reported in two patients. Mild asymptomatic induced limitation of adduction was reported in two cases. No other postoperative complications in the form of anterior segment ischemia or induced torsional diplopia were reported in any patient.

Discussion

Transposition of vertical rectus muscles has been considered as mainstay of treatment of complete sixth nerve palsy. Despite their various forms, all transposition procedures aim for improvement of the compromised abduction with correction of esotropia, face turn and expansion of the field of binocular single vision [13]. Traditional VRT procedures involve the simultaneous lateral transposition of part or the whole of both vertical rectus muscles at the same time. Single vertical rectus muscle transposition in the form of superior rectus transposition was proposed aiming for reduction of the incidence of postoperative anterior segment ischemia, especially when medial rectus muscle contracture mandates simultaneous recession of the medial rectus muscle [3, 4]. Since then, SRT has been studied in many articles concerning cases with defective ocular abduction secondary to chronic sixth nerve palsy and esotropic Duane retraction syndrome and its efficacy has been well established [4, 8, 9] [8,9,10]. Recently, a large retrospective analysis of induced vertical deviations secondary to SRT in sixth nerve palsy and esotropic Duane retraction syndrome was performed. The study comprised 69 patients who underwent SRT, 32 patients with sixth nerve palsy and 37 patients with esotropic Duane retraction. The study revealed that 14 patients developed hypertropic shift while 23 patients developed hypotropic shift. Out of these cases, 5 cases developed persistent vertical diplopia which required intervention [10].

The idea of IRT was first proposed by Velez and colleagues in 2017 to treat complete sixth nerve palsy in a series of 5 patients [11]. Because of their experience with induced hypertropia after SRT in sixth nerve palsy [9], they started transposing the inferior rectus muscle in patients with preoperative hypertropia. Their case series comprised 5 consecutive patients with sixth nerve palsy associated with preoperative hypertropia or more defective abduction in the down gaze. In terms of results, IRT scored significant improvement of esotropia, face turn and limited abduction with no reported cases of symptomatic induced vertical deviation. In the current study, we have evaluated our results with IRT on a series of 11 patients with chronic sixth nerve palsy. In general, we have found that IRT produces significant correction of esotropia, face turn, limited abduction with no reported cases of symptomatic induced vertical deviation, torsional diplopia or anterior segment ischemia.

In Velez study [11], average esotropia improvement was 27 PD, face turn correction was 26.4° with an average improvement of limited abduction by 1.0 unit. Compared with Velez study, our results are quite superior with an average improvement of esotropia by 35.9 PD, face turn correction by 25.9° and an average improvement of abduction limitation by 2.2 unit. We believe that our technique of dual augmentation of transposition compared with single muscle to muscle augmentation technique used by Velez and colleagues could explain such discrepancy. In addition, smaller number of patients in Velez study (5 patients) compared with the current one (11 patients) could also plays a role in such difference. One of the similar aspects between the current study and that of Velez is that IRT in both studies lead to collapse of the preoperative hypertropia by an average of 2.5 PD in the former and 1.2 PD in the latter. In Velez study, one patient developed 2PD induced hypertropia while another patient developed 3PD induced hypotropia. In the current study, two patients developed 2 PD induced hypotropia. In both studies, the induced vertical deviations were innocuous and of small magnitude which warranted no further interventions.

Recently, Sener and colleagues in 2019 evaluated IRT in management of 7 esotropic Duane retraction syndrome patients who had either more defective abduction in the inferior gaze or had V-pattern esotropia [14]. In their study, average esotropic correction was 19.6 PD, V-pattern collapse was 19.9 PD, face turn improvement was 16.4° with an average improvement of limitation of abduction by 1.3 unit. Induced hypertropia was reported in two patients which mandated secondary surgical intervention in one patient. Comparatively, the results of the current study in correction of esotropia, face turn and limited abduction are slightly better than those of Sener study. However, we believe that comparisons are quite irrelevant because of different characters of patients in both studies (esotropic Dune retraction syndrome vs. sixth nerve palsy). In addition, different augmentation techniques were used in Sener study which vary between resection of inferior rectus muscle in some cases and posterior scleral fixation suture in other cases. Nevertheless, we believe that Sener study holds a beneficial role in the evaluation of the efficacy and safety pattern of IRT procedure.

Limitations of the current study include its retrospective nature, small number of included patients, in addition to paucity of data regarding the effect of IRT on fundus torsion. However, and taking into account the relative recentness of IRT procedure, this study provides valuable insights into outcomes of a recently practiced transposition procedure. We have found that IRT is effective in management of esotropia, face turn, limited abduction associated with chronic sixth nerve palsy with collapse of preexisting V-pattern. In addition, the impact of IRT on collapse of preexisting hypertropia with low incidence of significant induced hypotropia, which was observed in Velez study as well as in the current study, could open new insights into potential implications of IRT in cases of Sixth nerve palsy with preoperative hypertropia. Base on its efficacy and low rate of significant postoperative complications such as induced vertical deviations and torsional diplopia, we believe that IRT could be considered in management options of chronic sixth nerve palsy especially in cases with V-Pattern esotropia and more abduction limitation in the downgaze. However, and as data on outcomes of IRT on cases of sixth nerve palsy which do not exhibit the aforementioned criteria are currently lacking, future studies with larger sample size are recommended.

Availability of data and materials

The datasets used and/or analysed during the current study are available from the corresponding author on reasonable request.

Abbreviations

IRT:

Inferior Rectus Transposition

MRRc:

Medial Rectus recession

VRT:

Vertical Rectus Transposition

SRT:

Superior Rectus Transposition

PD:

Prism Diopters

References

  1. Hummelshein E. Uber Schnentransplantation am Ague Ophthal Gesselschft. 1907;34:248–53.

    Google Scholar 

  2. Schillinger RJ. A new type of tendon transplant operation for abducens paralysis. J Int Coll Surg. 1959;31(5):593–600.

    CAS  PubMed  Google Scholar 

  3. Johnston SC, Crouch ER Jr, Crouch ER. An innovative approach to transposition surgery is effective in treatment of Duane’s syndrome with esotropia [ARVO abstract]. Invest Ophthalmol Vis Sci. 2006;47:e-abstract 2475.

    Google Scholar 

  4. Mehendale RA, Dagi LR, Wu C, Ledoux D, Johnston S, Hunter DG. Superior rectus transposition and medial rectus recession for Duane syndrome and sixth nerve palsy. Arch Ophthalmol. 2012;130(2):195–201.

    Article  Google Scholar 

  5. Foster RS. Vertical muscle transposition augmented with lateral fixation. J AAPOS. 1997;1:20–30.

    Article  CAS  Google Scholar 

  6. Wright KW. Transposition surgery for rectus muscle palsy. In: Wright KW, Thompson L, editors. Color atlas of strabismus surgery: Springer Science Business Media, LLC; 2007. p. 164–5.

    Google Scholar 

  7. Farid MF. Dual-augmented transposition of vertical recti in chronic abducens palsy. Am J Ophthalmol. 2019;197:59–64.

    Article  Google Scholar 

  8. Liu Y, Wen W, Zou L, et al. Application of SRT plus MR recession in supra-maximal esotropia from chronic sixth nerve palsy. Graefes Arch Clin Exp Ophthalmol. 2019;257:199–205.

    Article  Google Scholar 

  9. Velez FG, Oltra E, Isenberg SJ, Pineles SL. Assessment of torsion after superior rectus transposition with or without medial rectus recession for Duane syndrome and abducens nerve palsy. J AAPOS. 2014;18:457–60.

    Article  Google Scholar 

  10. Escuder AG, Kazlas MA, Heidary G, Hunter DG, Zurakowski D, Dagi LR. Incidence of symptomatic vertical and torsional diplopia after superior rectus transposition for esotropic Duane syndrome and abducens nerve palsy. J AAPOS. In press.

  11. Velez FG, Chang MY, Pineles SL. Inferior rectus transposition: a novel procedure for abducens palsy. Am J Ophthalmol. 2017;177:126–30.

    Article  Google Scholar 

  12. Farid MF, Elbarky AM, Saeed AM. Superior rectus and lateral rectus muscle union surgery in the treatment of myopic strabismus fixus: three sutures versus a single suture. J AAPOS. 2016;20:100–5.

    Article  Google Scholar 

  13. Farid MF. Sixth nerve palsy. In: Tejedor Jaime (editor). Strabismus and Amblyopia. Scientific Basis and Clinical Management. Madrid, Spain: McGraw-Hill; 2022. p. 401–410.

  14. Sener EC, Yilmaz PT, Fatihoglu ÖU. Superior or inferior rectus transposition in esotropic Duane syndrome: a longitudinal analysis. J Am Assoc Pediatr Ophthalmol Strabismus. 2019;23:21–e1.

    Google Scholar 

Download references

Acknowledgements

Not applicable.

Funding

Open access funding provided by The Science, Technology & Innovation Funding Authority (STDF) in cooperation with The Egyptian Knowledge Bank (EKB). The authors declare no funding body for this article.

Author information

Authors and Affiliations

Authors

Contributions

MFF: did conception and design of work, performed surgical tasks, data acquisition, interpretation and analysis, drafted and reviewed the manuscript. AAK: did data acquisition, interpretation and analysis, drafted and reviewed the manuscript. AME: did data acquisition, interpretation and analysis, drafted and reviewed the manuscript. All authors have read, reviewed and approved the manuscript in its current state.

Corresponding author

Correspondence to Mohamed F. Farid.

Ethics declarations

Ethics approval and consent to participate

This study was performed in accordance with tenets of the Declaration of Helsinki, The study protocol was approved by ethical committee, Benha Faculty of Medicine, Benha University. Due to its retrospective nature, this study was approved as exempt and obtaining informed consent from patients was waived by the Institutional Review Board, Benha Faculty of Medicine, Benha University.

Consent for publication

Written consent for the publication of identifying patient/clinical data as well as identifying images was obtained from all relevant patients. Written informed consent to publish any identifying patient, clinical data and identifying images was also obtained from the parents or legal guardians of children.

Competing interests

None of the authors has any conflicts of interest to disclose.

Additional information

Publisher’s Note

Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.

Rights and permissions

Open Access This article is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License, which permits use, sharing, adaptation, distribution and reproduction in any medium or format, as long as you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons licence, and indicate if changes were made. The images or other third party material in this article are included in the article's Creative Commons licence, unless indicated otherwise in a credit line to the material. If material is not included in the article's Creative Commons licence and your intended use is not permitted by statutory regulation or exceeds the permitted use, you will need to obtain permission directly from the copyright holder. To view a copy of this licence, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/. The Creative Commons Public Domain Dedication waiver (http://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/) applies to the data made available in this article, unless otherwise stated in a credit line to the data.

Reprints and Permissions

About this article

Verify currency and authenticity via CrossMark

Cite this article

Farid, M.F., Khater, A.A. & Elbarky, A.M. Augmented inferior rectus transposition with medial rectus recession in treatment of chronic unilateral sixth nerve palsy. BMC Ophthalmol 22, 337 (2022). https://doi.org/10.1186/s12886-022-02552-2

Download citation

  • Received:

  • Accepted:

  • Published:

  • DOI: https://doi.org/10.1186/s12886-022-02552-2

Keywords

  • Sixth nerve palsy
  • Rectus muscle transposition
  • Inferior rectus muscle