Folate and retinal vascular diseases

Abstract

Folate, a pteroylglutamic acid derivative, participates in fundamental cellular metabolism. Homocysteine, an amino acid, serves as an intermediate of the methionine cycle and can be converted back to methionine. Hyperhomocysteinemia is a recognized risk factor for atherosclerotic and cardiovascular diseases. In recent decades, elevated plasma homocysteine levels and low folate status have been observed in many patients with retinal vascular diseases, such as retinal vascular occlusions, diabetic retinopathy, and age-related degeneration. Homocysteine-induced toxicity toward vascular endothelial cells might participate in the formation of retinal vascular diseases. Folate is an important dietary determinant of homocysteine. Folate deficiency is the most common cause of hyperhomocysteinemia. Folate supplementation can eliminate excess homocysteine in plasma. In in vitro experiments, folic acid had a protective effect on vascular endothelial cells against high glucose. Many studies have explored the relationship between folate and various retinal vascular diseases. This review summarizes the most important findings that lead to the conclusion that folic acid supplementation might be a protective treatment in patients with retinal vascular diseases with high homocysteine or glucose status. More research is still needed to validate the effect of folate and its supplementation in retinal vascular diseases.

Introduction

Folate, a collective term for a family of water-soluble vitamins (vitamin B9), plays an essential part in one-carbon metabolism, which primarily involves the metabolism of key amino acids and nucleic acids [1]. It has two forms, including naturally occurring folate and folic acid [2]. Natural folate was first found by Lucy Wills in 1931. It was extracted from yeast and could prevent and cure the macrocytic anemia that often occurred in late pregnancy [3]. Folic acid, an oxidized and stable synthetic form of vitamin B₉, can only be obtained from fortified food, supplements, and pharmaceuticals. Mammals cannot self-synthesize folate. Hence, folate can only be obtained through dietary sources and folate supplementation. Folate deficiency is often caused by inadequate dietary intake, which can lead to several human disorders, such as megaloblastic anemia and neural tube defects in fetuses [4], as well as cardiovascular disease, certain types of cancer, and cognitive diseases [5, 6]. Folate, as a cofactor, plays an important part in one-carbon metabolisms which is required in multiple biological processes including DNA synthesis, DNA reparation and production of methionine by methylation of homocysteine.

Homocysteine, an amino acid, serves as an intermediate in the methionine cycle. It can be converted back to methionine or transsulfrated to cysteine. 5-Methyltetrahydrofolate (5-mTHF) serves as a cofactor for the remethylation of homocysteine into methionine via methionine synthase, a vitamin B12-dependent enzyme. Deficiency of folate or vitamin B12 can lead to the elevation of plasma homocysteine levels [5]. In the early 1990s, elevated plasma homocysteine levels became a recognized risk factor for atherosclerotic disease [7]. In addition, elevated plasma homocysteine levels have been reported as a risk factor for stroke, dementia, and retinal vascular occlusive diseases [8,9,10]. Moreover, homocysteine was found to induce endothelial dysfunction in hyperhomocysteinemia [11]. Many retinal vascular problems occur in hyperhomocysteinemia such as retinal vascular occlusions and diabetic retinopathy. Retinal vascular diseases are abnormalities that affect the blood vessels in the eyes and are the main causes of visual impairment and blindness worldwide [12]. Many studies have found that low plasma folate levels and elevated homocysteine levels are independent risk factors for some retinal vascular diseases, including central retinal vein occlusion (CRVO) and diabetic retinopathy (DR) [13, 14]. Moreover, daily folic acid supplementation could effectively reduce the concentration of homocysteine and may protect vascular endothelial cells [15]. In this review, we discuss the biochemistry of folate, its role as a risk factor for retinal vascular diseases, and treatment studies with folate supplementation.

Biochemistry of folic acid

Folate is a collective name for a family of water-soluble vitamins (vitamin B9) that have similar properties and share a similar structure with pteroylglutamic acid [16]. It includes natural folate and folic acid. In nature, folate exists in leafy green vegetables, fresh fruits, beans, nuts, liver, and kidneys, mainly as 5-methyltetrahydrofolate and formyltetrahydrofolate [17, 18]. Folic acid is an oxidized and stable synthetic form of folate that can only be obtained from fortified food, supplements, and pharmaceuticals [5]. Its chemical structure is illustrated in Fig. 1.Both natural folates and folic acid are converted into 5-mTHF, the final product of the folate cycle, which is the principal active metabolite of folate. Its stable calcium salt is widely used for pharmaceutical use [19].

Fig. 1

Chemical structure of folic acid

Food folates (polyglutamate derivatives) are hydrolyzed at the mucosal epithelial cell brush border by folyl-poly-glutamate carboxypeptidase to the monoglutamate form [20]. Then, both food folates and folic acid are absorbed in the proximal small intestine (jejunum) via the proton-coupled folate transporter [21]. In mucosal cells, folic acid is reduced to tetrahydrofolate (THF) by dihydrofolate reductase (DHFR). (Fig. 2) Then, THF is metabolized to 5-mTHF with the aid of serine hydroxymethyltransferase and 5,10-methylenetetrahydrofolate reductase (MTHFR) [20]. 5-mTHF is both an active and final product of folate in the body, which accounts for approximately 98% of folates in human plasma [5]. After absorption, it is released into the portal circulation, most of it is taken up by the liver, and the rest of it is secreted into the gut by the bile duct and recirculated by the enterohepatic cycle [22]. Endogenous folate exists in free and combined forms in plasma [1].

Fig. 2

Main metabolic pathways of folate

Folate has an important role in one-carbon metabolism, which primarily involves the metabolism of serine and histidine and the synthesis of thymidylate, methionine, and purine [1]. The critical components of one-carbon metabolism are the folate and methionine cycles. THF is an intermediate carrier of a single carbon unit because of its unique chemical structure with the presence of a pterin core, which has π-electron-deficient properties and makes it easy to accept a carbon unit [19, 23]. With the help of serine hydroxymethyltransferase, THF forms 5,10-methylene-THF by accepting a single carbon group from serine and generating glycine at the same time. Afterward, 5,10-methylene-THF participates in the formation of deoxythymidine monophosphate (dTMP) and dihydrofolate (DHF) by reducing and methylating deoxyuridine monophosphate, catalyzed by the thymidylate synthase enzyme [24]. dTMP is next involved in the synthesis of DNA. DHF can re-enter the folate cycle and be reduced to THF. In the methionine cycle, methionine generates S-adenosylmethionine (SAM) via the adenylation of methionine by methionine adenosyltransferase. SAM, as the methyl donor, donates a methyl group to the histone and generates S-adenosylhomocysteine (SAH) by histone methyltransferases (HMTs). Then, SAH further generates homocysteine. Homocysteine is eliminated by producing cysteine via Cystathionine-beta-synthase (CBS) (Fig. 2). Homocysteine is the intermediate product of the methionine cycle and can be converted back to methionine by donation of a methyl group from 5-mTHF or betaine [25]. Therefore, the complete methionine cycle needs the assistance of folate, and folate deficiency can impair the remethylation of homocysteine and cause the accumulation of homocysteine and abnormal one-carbon metabolism. From another aspect, plasma homocysteine concentration is an indirect indicator of folate level [26].

Folate and retinal vascular occlusions

Retinal vascular occlusions are common causes of visual loss. Retinal vascular occlusions can be divided into two main types: retinal artery occlusion (RAO) and retinal vein occlusion (RVO). These two main types of occlusions have different etiologies, pathogeneses, and clinical features. However, both are closely related to aging and cardiovascular risk factors. RVO is more prevalent than RAO and seems to have much better endpoints [27]. Retinal vascular occlusion can be divided into the central vascular occlusion type and branch vascular occlusion type according to the scope of occlusion.

Homocysteine, a sulfur-containing amino acid, is an intermediate product of methionine metabolism. Elevated plasma homocysteine levels, a prothrombotic state, are an accepted risk factor for atherosclerosis and cardiovascular diseases [28]. Hyperhomocysteinemia is defined as a fasting total plasma homocysteine level greater than 15 µmol/L. Homocysteine has been considered to injure vascular endothelial cells by impairing the endothelium’s capacity, increasing pro-thrombotic platelet function, inducing the production of pro-inflammatory cytokines, and mediating the apoptotic cell death of endothelial cells [29]. Hyperhomocysteinemia will sustain a snowball-like effect and irreversibly impair endothelial cells. The causes of hyperhomocysteinemia include dietary deficiencies of the vitamin B complex, genetic defects such as a thermolabile variant of MTHFR, clinical conditions such as renal failure, and some drugs, such as methotrexate and theophylline [30].

Many clinical studies have reported that plasma homocysteine levels are significantly higher in patients with retinal vascular occlusive disease and have suggested that hyperhomocysteinemia is a risk factor for retinal vascular occlusion disease [9, 31,32,33,34]. Some case-control studies found that the plasma homocysteine level in the patient group was significantly higher than that in the control group and assumed that hyperhomocysteinemia was a risk factor for both RAO and RVO diseases [14, 35,36,37,38,39,40]. Table 1 summarizes clinical trials investigating the associations between homocysteine as well as folate and RAO, RVO. The most common cause of retinal artery disease is embolism, which mostly comes from the carotid artery and the heart [41]. It was found that hyperhomocysteinemia, as a recognized risk factor for thrombosis, was associated with an increased incidence of retinal emboli in an older population-based cross-sectional study [42]. The association between hyperhomocysteinemia and RAO disease was confirmed by a meta-analysis of cohort studies [43]. In the aforementioned studies, folate was used to reduce plasma homocysteine concentrations.

Table 1 Clinical trials investigating the associations between homocysteine and folate and RAO and RVO

Likewise, a review reported that hyperhomocysteinemia could increase central retinal vein occlusion (CRVO) risk and is a critical factor in the development of CRVO [45]. A meta-analysis demonstrated that retinal vascular occlusion was significantly correlated with elevated plasma total homocysteine levels and low serum folate levels [46]. Folate supplementation was used to lower the plasma hyperhomocysteine concentration by converting hyperhomocysteine to methionine. Initially, the benefit of folic acid on RVO was considered to be the result of a reduction in plasma total homocysteine concentrations. However, many studies have found that a large number of RVO patients, especially CRVO patients, always have elevated plasma homocysteine levels and low plasma folate levels. Therefore, many scholars assume that low folate status is an independent risk factor for CRVO. Some case-control studies were conducted to determine the relationship between folate status and CRVO. Gao et al. [14] reported an odds ratio (OR) of 1.3 for plasma folate in patients with CRVO in the Chinese population, and an OR of 6.13 (95% confidence interval (CI) 3.85–9.76, P < 0.0001) was reported by another study conducted in Florence [39]. Another case-control study found that RVO patients had lower serum folate levels than population-based controls of similar age and sex (P < 0.0001) and suggested that treatment with folate supplementation may be useful [38]. A meta-analysis also found the plasma folate level was significantly lower in RVO patients compared with controls (P = 0.001), as well as in CRVO patients (P = 0.006), and indicated that low serum folate levels were a risk factor of RVO [38]. A study even suggested that any patients with elevated homocysteine levels should be treated with folic acid supplementation [47]. Availble studies suggested that hyperhomocysteinmia was an risk factors for RVO and RAO. Compared with RVO, only a few researchers have aimed to investigate the association between hyperhomocysteinemia and RAO. This seems to be due to the lower incidence of RAO than RVO. Moreover, because of the small sample size and amount of research, more studies are needed to confirm the association between hyperhomocysteinemia and RAO. .

In some cases, retinal vascular occlusive disease occurs in young adults with no other systemic disease or comorbidity but a high homocysteine status [48,49,50]. In some case reports, RAO occurred in young patients with a homozygous MTHFR genetic defect [51, 52]. Interestingly, another case report presented a 12-year-old girl with CRVO, and the existence of a homozygous C677T MTHFR mutation emerged in retinal neovascularization twelve years after the first treatment. Folate deficiency with the existence of an MTHFR genetic defect could cause hyperhomocysteinemia and then accelerate atherosclerosis or thrombosis and even neovascularization [53]. Folate supplementation should be considered in those patients who have MTHFR genetic defects accompanied by folate deficiency. Folic acid is essential for cell survival and growth. Folic acid also has several beneficial effects on vascular endothelial cells in addition to reducing homocysteine-induced toxic effects by lowering plasma homocysteine levels. Folic acid can protect human umbilical vein endothelial cells (HUVECs) from injury caused by hypoxia by targeting the ERK1/2/NOX/ROS pathway [54]. Another study found that folic acid can inhibit cell apoptosis and reduce homocysteine-induced toxicity by regulating the expression of apoptosis-related genes in HUVECs [55]. These studies illustrate the function of folic acid in HUVECs, and its effect on ocular needs to be assessed by more studies.

Folate and diabetic retinopathy

DR is the leading cause of visual impairment in working-age people [56]. DR is a specific microvascular complication of diabetes mellitus (DM) characterized by functional and morphological changes in the retina. DR can be classified into nonproliferative DR and proliferative DR according to the presence of neovascularization. As the most advanced stage of DR, proliferative DR is characterized by neovascularization and proliferative membrane formation, which may cause vitreous hemorrhage and tractional retinal detachment, resulting in progressive vision loss. The mechanism of DR pathogenesis is diverse and complicated, including activation of inflammatory pathways, endoplasmic reticulum (ER) stress, reactive oxygen species production, overexpression of vascular endothelial growth factor, and genetic and epigenetic factors [57].

Since homocysteine was found to have toxic effects on vascular endothelial cells, the association between homocysteine and the prevalence of retinopathy was investigated. Some patients with diabetes were also observed to have hyperhomocysteinemia. However, the association between retinopathy and homocysteine is controversial. Retinopathy, similar to microangiopathy, was initially not found to be associated with elevated plasma homocysteine concentrations [58,59,60]. However, unlike these inconsistent results, proliferative DR was observed to be related to homocysteine concentrations in type 2 diabetes mellitus (T2DM) [61]. Some observations supported that elevated plasma homocysteine levels were an independent risk factor for the development and progression of DR in T2DM [13, 62]. Recently, a research team focused on homocysteine’s role in human visual disorders, especially DR and other age-related diseases. They found that hyperhomocysteinemia breaks up inner and outer blood-retinal barriers, induces retinal ischemia and neovascularization, activates oxidative and ER stresses, and induces epigenetic modifications [11, 63,64,65]. They found that the underlying mechanism of these pathologies induced by hyperhomocysteinemia is inflammation, which is mediated by NF-κB activation and regulation of inflammation-related cytokines [66]. Hence, they suggested that homocysteine may be a potential biological marker and a therapeutic target for DR [66, 67].

The concentration of plasma homocysteine is always associated with the status of B vitamins. A study analyzed the data from eligible diabetic patients from the US National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey from 2003 to 2018 and found that dietary folate intake could decrease the risk of DR [68]. Metanx, a prescription product, contains L-methylfolate calcium, which is the active form of vitamins B9 and other essential B vitamins (B6 and B12) [69]. It has been used to relieve the symptoms of diabetic neuropathy in diabetic patients. In recent decades, metanx was found to have positive impacts on endothelial dysfunction [70,71,72,73]. A pilot study found that metanx treatment seemed to help reduce retinal edema and increase light sensitivity in patients with nonproliferative DR [74]. An animal experiment showed that metanx inhibited measures of oxidative stress and inflammation and might assist in inhibiting diabetes-induced defects in visual function [69]. A meta-analysis found that folic acid supplementation may reduce total homocysteine levels in T2DM patients and has a trend to be associated with better glycemic control compared with placebo [75]. In addition to vitamin supplementation, there are also many clinical studies exploring the relationship between folate status and DM patients with or without DR. Fotiou et al. [13]found that patients with DR had significantly lower serum folate (P < 0.001) than those without DR in T2DM, and plasma levels of folate and vitamin B12, as the determinants of serum homocysteine concentration, may also affect DR risk. Moreover, they suggested that monitoring plasma folate levels could be used as an indicator for assessing the risk of DR. A study found that T2DM patients with proliferative DR and nonproliferative DR had significantly low folate status [76]. Folic acid may play a role in the development and progression of DR. Folic acid was found to protect retinal vascular endothelial cells against high glucose-induced injury from several aspects. Folic acid can diminish the expression of YAP1 and TEAD1 in the Hippo signaling pathway. The Hippo signaling pathway is associated with angiogenesis, which is the major pathological change in DR [77]. Furthermore, an animal study found that folic acid could protect the retina from thinning in the early stage of DR in diabetes mouse models by downregulating a panel of genes associated with angiogenesis, inflammation, and oxidative stress [78]. Folic acid could regulate the metabolism of DNA methylation, a kind of epigenetic change, in retinal microvessel cells against high glucose [79]. These experimental findings illustrate the possible mechanism of the protective effect of folic acid in DR. More studies still need to be conducted to confirm the association between folic acid and DR and the effect of folic acid supplementation.

Folate and other retinal vascular diseases

As mentioned above, homocysteine has been recognized as a risk factor for cardiovascular diseases and age-related diseases. Age-related macular degeneration (AMD), which affects photoreceptors, retinal pigment epithelium (RPE), Bruch’s membrane, and the choroid complex, is the leading cause of irreversible visual impairment, accounting for 6–9% of global blindness [80]. The mechanism of folate against AMD might be through the prevention of elevated serum homocysteine by promoting the elimination of homocysteine [81]. Some studies reported that the plasma concentration of homocysteine was significantly increased in AMD patients compared with the control group [82,83,84,85]. A cross-sectional analysis found that patients with late-stage AMD had significantly lower folate intakes compared with controls (P < 0.0001) and folate had no statistically significant association with AMD [86]. Nevertheless, several observational studies reported that serum folate was significantly associated with AMD risk [84, 87, 88]. A post hoc analysis of two age-related eye disease studies found that higher dietary intake of multiple nutrients including folate was associated with decreased risk of progression to late-stage AMD [89]. Some studies also suggested that a healthy diet rich in B vitamins, including folic acid, might reduce the risk of AMD and vision loss due to AMD [84, 87]. The Mediterranean diet, a diet with large consumption of vegetables, fruits, and nuts, is rich in B vitamins and minerals and can be recommended. More studies are needed to determine the effects of folic acid on AMD.

Bilateral retinal hemorrhages were observed in a 33-year-old man with macrocytic anemia and dietary folate deficiency in a case report. They assumed that retinal hemorrhage was a complication of the hyperdynamic retinal circulation and tissue hypoxia induced by severe macrocytic anemia, which seemed to be the result of folate deficiency [90]. A study observed significantly increased cerebrospinal folate levels in cerebral malaria patients after effective treatment of the acute malaria phase [91]. A comment suggested that folate deficiency might participate in the mechanism of retinal hemorrhages in cerebral malaria [92]. To date, its specific mechanism remains unclear.

Folate Supplementation

External folate supplementation includes folic acid, L-methylfolate, folinic acid, etc. Mandatory folic acid fortification of grain products has been used in certain countries, such as Canada, and has succeeded in decreasing the rates of neural tube defects by 20%~50%. Folic acid supplementation has been proven to reduce the risk of neural tube defects [93, 94]. It is widely used to treat hyperhomocysteinemia and folate deficiency. It has been shown that daily folic acid supplementation of 0.5-5.0 mg folic acid could reduce plasma homocysteine levels by approximately a quarter to a third, typically in the western population [15, 95]. However, long-term consumption of folic acid supplementation is controversial. Due to the improvement in diet and volunteer intake of fortified food and supplements, some people may ingest excess folate (upper limit: 1 mg). In 2015, the WHO defined high folate status as plasma folate greater than 45.3 nmol/L [96]. The imbalance of high folate status and low vitamin B12 could predispose pregnant women to diabetes and their offspring to insulin resistance [97]. High folic acid intake may increase the risk of certain types of cancer, including colorectal cancer and prostate cancer [98, 99]. Numerous studies have been conducted to investigate the controversial effect of folic acid on cancer risk. Some studies conclude that folic acid supplementation will not influence overall and site-specific cancer incidence [100, 101]. This controversy may be relevant to folate status, cancer stage, different baseline information, etc. More studies are still needed to explore the effect of folic acid supplementation on cancer risk. For retinal vascular diseases, a systematic review indicated that folic acid supplements (2.5 mg) could not prevent AMD and increased the risk of development of AMD. [102]. Another concern is that a high intake of folic acid may mask the appearance of vitamin B12 anemia and may interact with DHFR inhibitors such as methotrexate, making it less effective [5, 103]. A pilot study showed that a three-month vitamin supplementation containing L-methylfolate could significantly reduce plasma homocysteine levels in patients with diabetes [104]. L-methylfolate is as effective as folic acid in improving folate status and less likely to mask the appearance of vitamin B12-induced anemia and interact with DHFR inhibitors. Although folate supplementation could effectively reduce plasma homocysteine levels, its roles in the reduction of intracellular homocysteine toxicity, the therapeutic effect, and the prevention of retinal vascular diseases remain uncertain. Moreover, it may even increase the risk of development of AMD or certain types of cancer. It can not be recommended unless the clear evidence of benefit is needed.

Discussion

High plasma homocysteine levels are independent risk factors for RVO, which is essentially associated with major vascular factors and is considered as a form of atherosclerosis. Hyperhomocysteinemia, as a prothrombotic state, is a recognized risk factor for atherosclerosis and is usually the consequence of folate deficiency and, to a lesser extent, vitamin B12 deficiency. According to the available studies, both low plasma folate levels and high plasma homocysteine levels are independent risk factors for RVO. For AMD and DR, hyperhomocysteinmia has been considered as an independent risk factor. And yet it is still not certain that folic acid is an independent risk factor for AMD, only that it is associated with disease progression. These studies do not show an internal relationship between them. Retinal vasculopathy due to low folate status, which is essentially high homocysteine endangering the retinal vascular. Moreover, folic acid supplementation can effectively reduce and control plasma homocysteine levels and relief the high homocysteine-induced damage. The pathophysiologic changes caused by hyperhomocysteinemia are illustrated in Fig. 3. These pathways could be therapeutic targets and the role of folate stills needs more exploration. A systematic review reported that folic acid supplementation may improve endothelia function by increasing flow-mediated dilation and the percentage of flow-mediated dilation. The intrinsic mechanism is to improve the bioavailability of nitric oxide and to act as a direct scavenger of oxygen species, both of which are mediated independently of its homocysteine-lowering effect. [105, 106] Folate is essential for many important process such as cells growth and cell proliferation. Several animal studies suggested that folic acid can suppress on angiogenesis, inflammation and oxidative stress through epigenetic regulation to counteract diabetic retinopathy progression. [78, 79] In addition to protecting endothelial cells from homocysteine-induced toxic effects, folate has been found that it could inhibit cell apoptosis by regulating the expression of apoptosis-related genes in HUVECs. Hence, folate may have a protective effect against retinal vascular diseases. More prospective clinical studies are needed to explore the effect of folic acid supplementation on protection and prevention.

Fig. 3

Pathophysiological changes caused by hyperhomocysteinemia

Conclusion

Folate, as a critical cofactor of the one-carbon cycle, can reduce the serum homocysteine level via methionine metabolism. Some studies have suggested that hyperhomocysteinemia is independent risk factors for RVO, AMD and nonproliferative DR (in T2DM). Folate status is associated with the severity of DR and progression of AMD. The present review provides evidence that dietary folate intake is thought to have a protective effect on some ocular vascular diseases that are damaged by hyperhomocysteinemia and high glucose. For its effect on the treatment and prevention of diseases, there is still insufficient and uniform evidence. Therefore, further studies are required to assess the effect of folate or its supplementation on retinal vascular diseases in a large population.